The same argument again, with a different person. Saying yes again when we wanted to say no. The same kind of partner, the same boss with a different face, the same Sunday-evening tiredness. And the question that comes up, sometimes with anger and sometimes with sadness: why does this always happen to me?
Carl Gustav Jung’s analytical psychology has an answer that can feel uncomfortable at first. And then, very often, it brings relief.
What we don’t look at inside, we meet outside
In one of his books, Aion, Jung wrote a sentence that is often quoted, almost always in shortened form. In the original it says something like this: when an inner situation is not made conscious, it happens outside, as fate.
He isn’t talking about punishment or bad luck. He is talking about something we see every day in practice: what we don’t recognise in ourselves tends to show up in what happens to us, in the relationships we choose, in the situations that repeat. As if life kept putting in front of us, again and again, what we haven’t yet been able to look at.
Complexes: when something reacts for us
Jung called complexes the clusters of memories, emotions and images that form around important experiences, often from childhood. We all have them. They aren’t an illness: they are part of how the psyche is made.
A complex shows itself when we react more strongly than the situation calls for. A small criticism that ruins the whole day. A tone of voice that makes us feel ten years old again. In those moments, as Jung put it, it isn’t that we have a complex: the complex has us.
And what isn’t seen gets repeated. Not because we are clumsy, but because that part of us is acting without being heard.
The shadow: what we learned to leave out
Another central idea in Jung is the shadow: everything about us that at some point had no place. Anger that wasn’t allowed, a need we were ashamed of, ambition, fragility. It doesn’t disappear: it gets stored away.
One clue to finding it is to notice what bothers us too much in other people. Often, what irritates us most outside has something to do with what we don’t accept inside. Jung called this projection.
What comes back is not a failure: it is an invitation
From this perspective, what repeats isn’t a sign that we are failing. It is the psyche insisting. A dream that returns, a habit that won’t go, a conflict that changes setting but not shape: all of it carries something that asks to be looked at.
Often, what repeats was born to protect us. Always saying yes may once have been the way not to lose someone’s affection. Doing everything alone may have been the way not to depend on anyone who might let us down. Before trying to change it, it is worth understanding what it protected us from.
Making it conscious is more than understanding
Making the unconscious conscious isn’t having a brilliant explanation of why we do what we do. Many people understand their pattern perfectly and keep repeating it. Making it conscious means recognising it while it is happening: in the body, in the emotion, in the image that appears.
And the next step isn’t to get rid of that part, but to integrate it: give it a place, listen to it, find another way for it to do its job. Jung called this path individuation: becoming more and more who one really is, with light and shadow.
Some questions to start with
- What repeats in my life? In relationships, at work, in the body. Writing it down helps you see it.
- What do I feel just before? The pattern usually gives a warning: a tension, a familiar thought, a knot in the stomach.
- What did this once protect me from? Looking at it with gratitude, and not only with criticism, changes your relationship with it.
- What bothers me too much in other people? It may be a door to your own shadow.
- What do I dream? Writing down dreams on waking, without interpreting them straight away, is one of the oldest ways of listening to the unconscious.
Work best done with someone alongside
This path isn’t walked in a weekend or by reading an article. Looking at the shadow can hurt, which is why it is best done in a safe space, at each person’s pace and without judgement.
That is what I offer in psychotherapy grounded in analytical psychology: listening to what repeats, to dreams and images, not to correct ourselves but to understand ourselves, and to choose instead of repeating. Discover the Jungian approach →
Sources
- Jung, C. G. (1951). Aion: Researches into the Phenomenology of the Self. Collected Works, vol. 9/2, §126.
- Jung, C. G. (1934). “A review of the complex theory”. Collected Works, vol. 8.
- Jung, C. G. (1951). Aion, ch. 2, “The shadow”. Collected Works, vol. 9/2.