“I tried meditating, but I’m no good at it: I can’t stop thinking.”
It is probably the sentence I hear most when I talk about mindfulness, in my practice, in workshops with teams and among friends. And I always give the same answer: I can’t stop thinking either. Nobody can. And you don’t need to.
The mind thinks, the way the heart beats
Asking the mind not to think is like asking the sea not to have waves. Thinking is what the mind does.
A Harvard University study measured this with an app that asked more than 2,000 people, at random moments of the day, what they were doing and what they were thinking about. Almost half the time, their mind was on something else. And in almost every activity, at least a third of the time. That is how the human mind works.
The same study found something else: people were less happy when their mind was far from what they were doing. Not because thinking is bad, but because those thoughts often drag us along: to what went wrong yesterday, to what could go wrong tomorrow.
Meditating is getting to know your thoughts, not throwing them out
In my training as a mindfulness teacher there is an idea I come back to often: meditating isn’t emptying the mind, but becoming familiar with thinking. It is learning to see thoughts as they pass, without obeying them and without fighting them.
If we try to suppress them, they come back stronger. But if we look at them with a little curiosity, we start to notice something: they appear, stay for a while and go. Like bubbles rising from the bottom of a pot and dissolving at the surface. Like something written on water.
When we recognise a thought for what it is, a thought, it loses much of its power. “This is going to go wrong” stops being a truth and becomes something the mind is saying right now. And then we can choose what to do with it.
The moment you notice: that is meditating
This is what I most love to share, because it completely changes the experience of practising.
You sit down, bring your attention to the breath and, a few seconds later, you’re thinking about the shopping list. Many people believe that is where they failed. But the instant you notice you have wandered off, and come back, is the practice. It isn’t a mistake in meditation: it is meditation.
Every time you notice you got distracted and come back kindly, you are training attention, like repeating an exercise at the gym. A session in which you wandered off twenty times and came back twenty times isn’t a bad session. It is a session with twenty repetitions.
A practice to try: notice and return
- Sit comfortably, with your back upright but not rigid. You can close your eyes or keep your gaze lowered.
- Choose an anchor: the breath at the nose or the belly, your feet on the floor, or the sounds around you.
- When a thought appears, and it will, name it silently with one word: “thinking”, “planning”, “remembering”, “worrying”.
- Return to the anchor, without scolding yourself. Like calling back a puppy that wandered off to explore.
- Start with three minutes. That is enough. What matters isn’t how long it lasts, but doing it again.
What our thoughts also tell us
From the Jungian perspective I work with, thoughts that come back again and again aren’t just noise. Sometimes they carry something we haven’t heard yet: a worry, a wish, a wound. Mindfulness helps us not get caught in them. Psychotherapy, when it is needed, helps us understand what they have come to say.
So if you sit down to meditate and your mind won’t stop, don’t worry. You haven’t done anything wrong. That is exactly where it starts.
If you would like to learn to practise with guidance, I offer individual processes and programmes for teams, in Spanish, English or Portuguese. See how I work →
Sources
- Killingsworth, M. A., & Gilbert, D. T. (2010). A wandering mind is an unhappy mind. Science, 330(6006), 932. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1192439
- Kabat-Zinn, J. Ideas on “becoming familiar with thinking” and on thoughts as passing events, as presented in the materials of the Mindfulness Teacher Training (Asociación Argentina de Mindfulness).